National ICT Australia/US National Library of Medicine NCBI

Task 1

Strict Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Gene_expression         619 (  470)      769 (  470)    75.93    61.12    67.72
      Transcription          101 (   66)      231 (   66)    65.35    28.57    39.76
   Protein_catabolism         14 (    9)       20 (    9)    64.29    45.00    52.94
      Localization            99 (   31)       52 (   31)    31.31    59.62    41.06
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     =[SIMPLE ALL]=          833 (  576)     1072 (  576)    69.15    53.73    60.47
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
         Binding             333 (  107)      344 (  107)    32.13    31.10    31.61
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Protein_modification         1 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
     Phosphorylation         160 (   81)      111 (   81)    50.62    72.97    59.78
     Ubiquitination           30 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
       Acetylation             0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
      Deacetylation            0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    =[PROT-MOD ALL]=         191 (   81)      111 (   81)    42.41    72.97    53.64
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Regulation            288 (   27)      109 (   27)     9.38    24.77    13.60
   Positive_regulation      1130 (  235)      533 (  235)    20.80    44.09    28.26
   Negative_regulation       526 (  127)      249 (  127)    24.14    51.00    32.77
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   =[REGULATION ALL]=       1944 (  389)      891 (  389)    20.01    43.66    27.44
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[EVENT TOTAL]==       3301 ( 1153)     2418 ( 1153)    34.93    47.68    40.32
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span/Approximate Recursive

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Gene_expression         619 (  506)      761 (  506)    81.74    66.49    73.33
      Transcription          101 (   67)      230 (   67)    66.34    29.13    40.48
   Protein_catabolism         14 (    9)       20 (    9)    64.29    45.00    52.94
      Localization            99 (   31)       52 (   31)    31.31    59.62    41.06
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     =[SIMPLE ALL]=          833 (  613)     1063 (  613)    73.59    57.67    64.66
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
         Binding             333 (  107)      344 (  107)    32.13    31.10    31.61
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Protein_modification         1 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
     Phosphorylation         160 (   81)      111 (   81)    50.62    72.97    59.78
     Ubiquitination           30 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
       Acetylation             0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
      Deacetylation            0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    =[PROT-MOD ALL]=         191 (   81)      111 (   81)    42.41    72.97    53.64
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Regulation            288 (   33)      109 (   33)    11.46    30.28    16.62
   Positive_regulation      1130 (  257)      533 (  257)    22.74    48.22    30.91
   Negative_regulation       526 (  130)      249 (  130)    24.71    52.21    33.55
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   =[REGULATION ALL]=       1944 (  420)      891 (  420)    21.60    47.14    29.63
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[EVENT TOTAL]==       3301 ( 1221)     2409 ( 1221)    36.99    50.68    42.77
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span without Event Trigger Matching/Approximate Recursive

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Gene_expression         619 (  516)      747 (  511)    83.36    68.41    75.15
      Transcription          101 (   73)      215 (   73)    72.28    33.95    46.20
   Protein_catabolism         14 (    9)       19 (    9)    64.29    47.37    54.55
      Localization            99 (   33)       51 (   31)    33.33    60.78    43.06
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     =[SIMPLE ALL]=          833 (  631)     1032 (  624)    75.75    60.47    67.25
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
         Binding             333 (  122)      343 (  120)    36.64    34.99    35.79
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Protein_modification         1 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
     Phosphorylation         160 (   81)      111 (   81)    50.62    72.97    59.78
     Ubiquitination           30 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
       Acetylation             0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
      Deacetylation            0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    =[PROT-MOD ALL]=         191 (   81)      111 (   81)    42.41    72.97    53.64
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Regulation            288 (   35)      107 (   34)    12.15    31.78    17.58
   Positive_regulation      1130 (  266)      531 (  264)    23.54    49.72    31.95
   Negative_regulation       526 (  135)      249 (  132)    25.67    53.01    34.59
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   =[REGULATION ALL]=       1944 (  436)      887 (  430)    22.43    48.48    30.67
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[EVENT TOTAL]==       3301 ( 1270)     2373 ( 1255)    38.47    52.89    44.54
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Strict Matching/Decomposition

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event-Arg Type            gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Theme-Gene_expression           619 (  470)      769 (  470)    75.93    61.12    67.72
Theme-Transcription             101 (   66)      231 (   66)    65.35    28.57    39.76
Theme-Protein_catabolism         14 (    9)       20 (    9)    64.29    45.00    52.94
Theme-Binding                   418 (  212)      408 (  212)    50.72    51.96    51.33
Theme-Localization               99 (   31)       52 (   31)    31.31    59.62    41.06
Theme-Protein_modification        1 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Phosphorylation           160 (   85)      111 (   85)    53.12    76.58    62.73
Theme-Ubiquitination             25 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Acetylation                 0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Deacetylation               0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Regulation                257 (   36)      109 (   36)    14.01    33.03    19.67
Theme-Positive_regulation      1068 (  291)      539 (  291)    27.25    53.99    36.22
Theme-Negative_regulation       490 (  154)      248 (  154)    31.43    62.10    41.73
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=[THEME ALL]=                  3252 ( 1354)     2487 ( 1354)    41.64    54.44    47.19
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cause-Regulation                103 (    5)       10 (    5)     4.85    50.00     8.85
Cause-Positive_regulation       337 (   43)       67 (   43)    12.76    64.18    21.29
Cause-Negative_regulation       122 (   10)       16 (   10)     8.20    62.50    14.49
Cause-Protein_modification        0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Phosphorylation             2 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Ubiquitination              8 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Acetylation                 0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Deacetylation               0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=[CAUSE ALL]=                   572 (   58)       93 (   58)    10.14    62.37    17.44
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
==[PRIMARY ARG TOTAL]==        3824 ( 1412)     2580 ( 1412)    36.92    54.73    44.10
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span/Approximate Recursive/Decomposition

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event-Arg Type            gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Theme-Gene_expression           619 (  506)      761 (  506)    81.74    66.49    73.33
Theme-Transcription             101 (   67)      230 (   67)    66.34    29.13    40.48
Theme-Protein_catabolism         14 (    9)       20 (    9)    64.29    45.00    52.94
Theme-Binding                   418 (  215)      403 (  215)    51.44    53.35    52.38
Theme-Localization               99 (   31)       52 (   31)    31.31    59.62    41.06
Theme-Protein_modification        1 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Phosphorylation           160 (   85)      111 (   85)    53.12    76.58    62.73
Theme-Ubiquitination             25 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Acetylation                 0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Deacetylation               0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Regulation                257 (   42)      109 (   42)    16.34    38.53    22.95
Theme-Positive_regulation      1068 (  312)      539 (  312)    29.21    57.88    38.83
Theme-Negative_regulation       490 (  158)      248 (  158)    32.24    63.71    42.82
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=[THEME ALL]=                  3252 ( 1425)     2473 ( 1425)    43.82    57.62    49.78
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cause-Regulation                103 (    5)       10 (    5)     4.85    50.00     8.85
Cause-Positive_regulation       337 (   44)       67 (   44)    13.06    65.67    21.78
Cause-Negative_regulation       122 (   10)       16 (   10)     8.20    62.50    14.49
Cause-Protein_modification        0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Phosphorylation             2 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Ubiquitination              8 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Acetylation                 0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Deacetylation               0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=[CAUSE ALL]=                   572 (   59)       93 (   59)    10.31    63.44    17.74
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
==[PRIMARY ARG TOTAL]==        3824 ( 1484)     2566 ( 1484)    38.81    57.83    46.45
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span without Event Trigger Matching/Approximate Recursive/Decomposition

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event-Arg Type            gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Theme-Gene_expression           619 (  516)      747 (  511)    83.36    68.41    75.15
Theme-Transcription             101 (   73)      215 (   73)    72.28    33.95    46.20
Theme-Protein_catabolism         14 (    9)       19 (    9)    64.29    47.37    54.55
Theme-Binding                   418 (  244)      403 (  237)    58.37    58.81    58.59
Theme-Localization               99 (   33)       51 (   31)    33.33    60.78    43.06
Theme-Protein_modification        1 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Phosphorylation           160 (   85)      111 (   85)    53.12    76.58    62.73
Theme-Ubiquitination             25 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Acetylation                 0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Deacetylation               0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Theme-Regulation                257 (   46)      107 (   44)    17.90    41.12    24.94
Theme-Positive_regulation      1068 (  327)      535 (  322)    30.62    60.19    40.59
Theme-Negative_regulation       490 (  163)      248 (  159)    33.27    64.11    43.80
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=[THEME ALL]=                  3252 ( 1496)     2436 ( 1471)    46.00    60.39    52.22
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cause-Regulation                103 (    5)       10 (    5)     4.85    50.00     8.85
Cause-Positive_regulation       337 (   53)       66 (   53)    15.73    80.30    26.30
Cause-Negative_regulation       122 (   11)       16 (   11)     9.02    68.75    15.94
Cause-Protein_modification        0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Phosphorylation             2 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Ubiquitination              8 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Acetylation                 0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
Cause-Deacetylation               0 (    0)        0 (    0)     0.00     0.00     0.00
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=[CAUSE ALL]=                   572 (   69)       92 (   69)    12.06    75.00    20.78
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
==[PRIMARY ARG TOTAL]==        3824 ( 1565)     2528 ( 1540)    40.93    60.92    48.96
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Task 2

Strict Matching/Decomposition

N/A

Approximate Span/Approximate Recursive/Decomposition

N/A

Approximate Span without Event Trigger Matching/Approximate Recursive/Decomposition

N/A

Task 3

Strict Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
        Negation             143 (   17)       58 (   17)    11.89    29.31    16.92
       Speculation           195 (   21)       82 (   21)    10.77    25.61    15.16
     ==[MOD TOTAL]==         338 (   38)      140 (   38)    11.24    27.14    15.90
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span/Approximate Recursive

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
        Negation             143 (   22)       58 (   19)    15.38    32.76    20.94
       Speculation           195 (   28)       82 (   28)    14.36    34.15    20.22
     ==[MOD TOTAL]==         338 (   50)      140 (   47)    14.79    33.57    20.54
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span without Event Trigger Matching/Approximate Recursive

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
       Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
        Negation             143 (   22)       58 (   19)    15.38    32.76    20.94
       Speculation           195 (   30)       82 (   30)    15.38    36.59    21.66
     ==[MOD TOTAL]==         338 (   52)      140 (   49)    15.38    35.00    21.37
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thank you for your participation!!